This laid-back, tropical-themed hotel is 0.5 miles from Windley Key Fossil Reef Geological State Park and a 4-minute walk from the Theater of the Sea marine park. Island-style rooms with tile floors feature minifridges, microwaves and wet bars, as well as private porches with paths to the pool. There's an outdoor pool with a waterfall, a poolside barbecue pit and a sports pub and restaurant serving classic American fare and late-night bites.